Arthur Hayes Claims US Insurers Face Insolvency Over AI Debt Amid Accounting Practices

Arthur Hayes claims the U.S. insurance industry would be deemed insolvent if AI-related debts were valued at market rates, citing a 'captive reinsurance' structure that treats worthless promises as actual capital.
Forensic accountant Thomas Gober revealed through analyst Nick Nemeth that $154 billion in affiliated reinsurance collateralizes $6.57 billion in surplus funds, meaning 29 of the top 30 U.S. insurers would be technically insolvent without this structure. Vermont-based captive insurers hold just 3.7% of assets needed to fulfill their obligations.
If Hayes' claims are valid, a trigger could occur when AI data center debt credit ratings decline en masse. Insurers have expanded market share in the AI data center debt sector, with their solvency tied directly to whether AI research labs continue purchasing computing power.
Private credit funds already restricted investor withdrawals this year—a warning signal now linked to insurers' similar private credit debt burdens. State guaranty funds, designed to support failed insurers, cover only $250,000-$300,000 per policy and are funded by surviving insurers who also rely on the same reinsurance model.
Retirees holding insurance company pensions could face real losses if reinsurance backing proves insufficient. Hayes compares the situation to a domino effect: as AI companies slow computing power purchases, data center debt credit ratings fall, forcing insurers to cover more than they actually hold. Private credit funds have already shown similar stress, signaling potential broader issues.
Insurers' accounting practices artificially inflate reserve strength. If an insurer fails, the thin safety net—limited to $250,000-$300,000 per policy—comes from other insurers using the same risky model. This mirrors the 2008 housing crisis depicted in 'The Big Short,' where investor Steve Eiseman discussed similar risks on a podcast.
Hayes argues that either regulators allow insurers to fail and absorb fallout or government intervenes. He connects this to Federal Reserve policies, suggesting both paths could increase money supply—positively impacting Bitcoin (BTC). However, whether Hayes' claims hold depends on regulatory transparency; if the accounting gaps exist, the ripple effects could extend far beyond crypto markets.
Korean Source
This article is an English localization of a Korean-language crypto news report. Original headline: 아서 헤이스, 미국 보험사 AI 부채로 지급불능…사실일까?