Bitcoin Experts Advise Against High Retirement Fund Allocation

Bitcoin may be viewed as a long-term investment, but experts argue it's difficult to allocate significant portions of retirement funds to it. The focus should be on the volatility and loss risk at withdrawal time rather than potential high returns.
On August 8 (local time), blockchain media CoinTelegraph reported that pension industry and asset management firms are increasingly advocating for a limited allocation of Bitcoin in retirement portfolios, rather than making it a core component. A survey by the U.S. Retirement Security Institute found 77% of respondents considered including cryptocurrency in workplace retirement plans risky.
While some institutions leave room for potential inclusion with appropriate allocation, BlackRock suggests a reasonable Bitcoin allocation of 1-2% for risk-tolerant investors within diversified portfolios. Fidelity analyzes that allocating 2-5% of retirement portfolios to Bitcoin could improve long-term performance.
Digital asset financial advisor Ryan Pers explained that instead of simply adding cryptocurrency to existing portfolios, it should replace portions of other assets. Generally, he recommends not exceeding a 5% allocation for crypto in total investment assets.
The key issue is that Bitcoin's high volatility can be particularly detrimental to retirees. Younger investors may wait out market downturns, but those nearing or in retirement often need to withdraw funds for living expenses. Selling during a downturn makes it difficult to recover losses when prices rebound.
Retirement asset researcher Bill Bengen, who established the 4% withdrawal rule, prioritizes capital preservation in retirement portfolios. While acknowledging Bitcoin's potential utility, he recommends limiting its allocation to within 5% to avoid significant losses.
Institutional approaches remain cautious. Some pension funds and large investors indirectly invest in Bitcoin through regulated Bitcoin spot ETFs. Others choose exposure to the industry's growth by investing in related companies rather than cryptocurrency itself.
The largest public pension fund, CalPERS, is known to invest in Strategy, which holds the most Bitcoin among companies. CalSTRS, a large pension fund for educators, does not hold Bitcoin directly but invests in crypto-related companies like Coinbase instead.
Experts ultimately point out that whether Bitcoin will rise long-term and whether it can be afforded as retirement funds are separate issues. Even if believing in Bitcoin's long-term growth, retirees should not risk their entire portfolio on price recovery.
Professor Jonathan Parker of Massachusetts Institute of Technology also suggests that while cryptocurrency may have a place in diversified retirement portfolios, investing in stocks or debt of companies actually generating revenue in the crypto industry might be more prudent than direct Bitcoin investment.
Korean Source
This article is an English localization of a Korean-language crypto news report. Original headline: 비트코인, 은퇴자금에 얼마나 담을까…"5% 넘기지 말아야" 전문가 권고