Bitcoin Holding Method Tax-Adjusted Returns Differed in Simulation

A simulation assuming a 100% rise in Bitcoin (BTC) price calculated direct ownership's after-tax profit at 78.0%. Overseas spot ETFs saw lower returns as holding periods lengthened due to management fees. BitPlanet (049470) compared the return structures of direct ownership, overseas spot ETFs, and Bitcoin treasury company stocks in a report released on September 9. The firm calculated figures using public filings and exchange prices.
The National Tax Service announced that virtual asset gains from transfers or rentals after January 1, 2027, will be subject to separate taxation under miscellaneous income at a 20% rate with an annual deduction of 2.5 million won. Pre-2027 holdings will use the higher of the December 31, 2026 market value or acquisition cost as the basis. Including local income tax, the effective burden is calculated at 22%. Virtual asset taxes apply to capital gains, while domestic stock trading tax applies to total selling price, making direct comparisons difficult. Domestic listed stocks currently have a combined securities transaction tax burden of 0.20% for Kospi and Kosdaq as of 2026.
BitPlanet explained its treasury company stock price as 'BTC price × BTC per share × mNAV,' where BTC per share represents indirect Bitcoin holdings per share, and mNAV is the enterprise value divided by Bitcoin holdings. When companies raise funds to buy more BTC, increased holdings can outweigh dilution from new shares, raising BTC per share. Conversely, convertible bonds converting to stock may lower it.
As of June 2026, BitPlanet held 300 BTC. The report calculated a 13.2% increase in BTC per share for the first half of 2026, adding 35.04 BTC without new shares to grow holdings from 265 to 300 BTC. The company issued two convertible bonds totaling 7 billion won (KRW) and estimated a maximum dilution rate of 7.8% if both convert.
BitPlanet's mNAV rose from 1.23x on June 30, 2026, to 1.91x by August 31, while its stock price surged 88.3% and BTC (KRW on Upbit) rose 21.3%. The report calculated MSTR's mNAV at 0.80x and MetaPlanet (3350) at 0.75x as of August 31, noting BitPlanet's market cap includes non-BTC business value, so mNAV cannot be interpreted purely as a Bitcoin premium.
After-tax profit simulations showed overseas spot ETFs at 77.6% (1 year), 76.8% (3 years), 76.1% (5 years), and 74.1% (10 years), compared to direct ownership's 78.0%. Domestic treasury company stocks in the calculation reflected only trading tax upon sale, assuming BTC per share growth and stable mNAV. However, if mNAV falls or convertible bonds dilute shares, tax differences may not translate to stock performance.
The report emphasizes that return comparisons must consider taxes, management fees, BTC per share, mNAV, debt, convertible bond dilution, and existing business value. Domestic spot Bitcoin ETF adoption remains pending legal revisions; a bill by Rep. Min Byung-deok to include virtual assets in ETFs is under review by the Finance Committee.
Korean Source
This article is an English localization of a Korean-language crypto news report. Original headline: 세후 수익 78.0…비트코인 투자 방식별 비용 달랐다