Bitcoin L1 Privacy Proposal Raises Concerns Over Privacy Coin Differentiation

A technical proposal to apply privacy features that hide transaction information on Bitcoin (BTC) layer 1 has raised concerns about weakening the differentiation of privacy-centric cryptocurrencies such as Zcash and Monero. A paper discussing a method to implement private transactions on Bitcoin L1 without a soft fork was introduced, with Darkfost CryptoQuant analyst referencing it on October 25th. Darkfost stated he is not a developer and lacks technical background but called the idea 'very appealing,' suggesting it could align with Satoshi Nakamoto's original vision for Bitcoin as the network evolves.
The proposal centers on implementing transaction information protection directly within Bitcoin L1, without requiring separate blockchains or external services. The paper explored how to enable private transactions without changing existing consensus rules through a soft fork. Currently, Bitcoin's structure publicly reveals transaction records and fund movement paths, allowing address relationships to be traced through analysis even if addresses aren't linked to real names. If privacy features were implemented on L1, it could reduce information exposure within the Bitcoin ecosystem, enabling users to conduct private transactions without moving assets to separate networks or external services.
Darkfost noted that while this proposal doesn't mean privacy features will be officially adopted by the Bitcoin network, implementation would require technical validation, security checks, and consensus among developers and users. The analyst also warned that if widely used, privacy functionality could diminish the competitive edge of projects like Zcash and Monero, which prioritize transaction confidentiality as a core feature. However, the actual adoption depends on factors such as user growth to form sufficient transaction volume for obfuscation, wallet and exchange support, and regulatory considerations.
CoinTelegraph reported on October 25th that the 'Shielded Bitcoin' proposal draws inspiration from Zcash's structure, aiming to use Bitcoin as a data publishing and sorting layer while relying on separate indexers to verify transactions. The discussion remains centered around the paper and analyst assessments, with no official adoption timeline or decision presented in Bitcoin development discussions.
Korean Source
This article is an English localization of a Korean-language crypto news report. Original headline: 비트코인 L1 프라이버시 제안, 지캐시 차별성 약화 가능성