Bitcoin Rises Despite MSCI Index Removal Concerns

According to strategist Jo Consorti's October 19th video, the potential removal of Strategy from the MSCI index could lead to up to $2.8 billion in stock selling, but the direct impact on Bitcoin markets would be limited. However, there is a risk that reduced equity prices may weaken the company's ability to purchase additional Bitcoin.
Consorti clarified that MSCI index fund sales of Strategy shares are not expected to translate into Bitcoin selling, emphasizing that market focus should be on timing and ripple effects rather than the scale of forced liquidations. The MSCI index has a classification system for excluding companies deemed non-operational due to asset holdings.
Consorti explained that Strategy may face exclusion from the index based on this standard, with final removal lists set to be announced November 11th and changes effective by close of business November 30th. MSCI-tracking funds are estimated to hold approximately 13 million shares, or 3.1% of Strategy's equity, valued at $1.9-2.8 billion in expected sales.
He noted that daily average trading volume for Strategy stock is about $2.9 billion, meaning the forced liquidation amount is smaller than typical daily volumes. However, the concentration of selling at market close could create pressure, as index funds must sell shares at closing prices on removal dates, potentially triggering early sales by informed investors.
Consorti cited historical examples from S&P 500 and Nasdaq where price impacts were concentrated between announcement and removal dates. Strategy stock fell 9.5% to $136.72 on Friday following news of potential index removal, while Bitcoin only declined about 1%. He stressed that approximately 850,000 BTC remains on Strategy's balance sheet with no direct market impact from the forced sales.
Indirect pressure could arise if Strategy's stock price continues to fall, affecting its ability to purchase Bitcoin. The company uses proceeds from issuing stocks and dividend securities to buy Bitcoin, requiring a ratio of market value to net asset value exceeding 1 for efficiency. With this ratio near 1 currently, lower equity prices may reduce Bitcoin acquisition volumes.
Consorti also highlighted the expanding institutional access to Bitcoin through Wall Street channels, noting that combined assets under Charles Schwab and Vanguard could reach $24 trillion, with just 1% of Schwab's assets potentially flowing into Bitcoin ($13.3 billion)—nearly 47 times larger than Strategy's estimated forced sale amount.
U.S. spot Bitcoin ETFs hold approximately 1.28 million BTC and have seen net inflows of about $57 billion since launch, though there was a $760 million net outflow after October 7th. Consorti noted that 'the door is open but money hasn't fully come in yet,' emphasizing the need to distinguish between potential institutional scale and actual capital flows.
Ultimately, he concluded that the impact on Bitcoin will be less about immediate selling pressure and more about Strategy's funding capacity and other index providers' decisions. He stated that 'rules changed so computers now force sales,' arguing for separate evaluation of index removal concerns versus Bitcoin's long-term demand fundamentals.
Korean Source
This article is an English localization of a Korean-language crypto news report. Original headline: MSCI 지수 편출 우려에도 비트코인 제한적 하락…강제 매도 영향은