Chinese Court Recognizes Bitcoin as Civil Property in Dispute Case

A Chinese court has determined that if Bitcoin (BTC) borrowed cannot be returned, the original acquisition cost of the cryptocurrency may be used to calculate damages. According to a case published by Guangdong Higher People's Court on April 28, the court stated that virtual assets such as Bitcoin possess some characteristics of civil property under civil law, even though they cannot circulate as currency.
The case involved a dispute over digital asset repayment in Guangzhou Intermediate People's Court. In July 2023, Party A lent one BTC to Party B for return by July 3, with terms specifying that if the price was higher at repayment, compensation would be made in Bitcoin or CNY based on the market value; if lower, repayment would be in USDT or CNY equivalent to the original value. Late payments would incur a 24% annual interest rate.
Party A sent one BTC via Binance to Party B but did not receive it back by the agreed date. They sued for return of the Bitcoin and damages for late repayment, requesting compensation based on the Bitcoin-CNY exchange rate on the day the judgment took effect if physical return was impossible.
The Guangzhou court ruled that the repayment terms were invalid, as they allowed Party A to benefit from price increases without bearing the risk of price declines. The court also found that specifying repayment in CNY would effectively treat Bitcoin like currency for exchange and circulation.
However, the court determined that even though the agreement was void, Party B still had a duty to compensate for the property obtained under the invalid contract. Since physical return of Bitcoin was impossible, damages were calculated based on the actual acquisition cost rather than market rate. The court noted that Party A purchased 1.14 BTC for 228,200 yuan (approx. $44 million) via Binance and awarded 199,600 yuan (approx. $39 million) in damages.
The Guangdong High People's Court explained that due to Bitcoin’s prohibition on circulation in China, it is difficult to recognize legitimate market prices or valuation standards. Additionally, since Party A used a prohibited digital asset trading platform within China, they must bear the risk of price fluctuations beyond what the court recognizes.
Korean Source
This article is an English localization of a Korean-language crypto news report. Original headline: 中 법원, 비트코인 민사상 재산 인정..."반환 못하면 손해배상"