Clarity Act Failure Shifts Regulatory Focus to SEC and CFTC Amid Industry Concerns

The U.S. virtual asset market structure bill, known as the Clarity Act, has failed to pass, shifting regulatory leadership to financial authorities as industry voices express mixed views on regulatory progress and legal uncertainty.
According to CoinDesk on November 11 (U.S. time), the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) are accelerating efforts to establish virtual asset regulations following the legislative failure of the Clarity Act. However, experts remain uncertain whether administrative actions alone can provide long-term regulatory stability without congressional legislation.
The SEC introduced a five-year innovation exemption allowing blockchain-based tokenized stock trading on November 17, followed by a proposal on November 1 to permit virtual asset custody by registered investment companies and certain direct holdings by investment advisors and funds. The CFTC has also begun seeking public input on regulations for leveraged virtual asset trading for retail investors and a new market registration system as of November 5, though these measures remain in the preliminary notice stage before formal implementation.
Industry analysts suggest that regulatory reforms led by financial authorities could potentially accelerate market development. Matt Hogan, Chief Investment Officer at Bitwise, noted that with years likely needed for further legislative action after Congress passes regulations, direct agency actions may be advantageous in the short term. Paul McCaffrey, head of digital assets at KBW, explained that increased regulatory clarity has spurred more mergers and acquisitions across virtual assets, traditional finance, and fintech sectors.
Legal experts, however, caution that administrative regulation alone has limitations. Professor Lev Brado of William & Mary Law School pointed out that while the SEC and CFTC are refining regulations based on existing laws, a comprehensive federal oversight framework for general virtual asset spot trading remains absent. Kevin Crozier of D3 Legal Advisors added that regulatory actions are welcome but do not provide the same level of long-term certainty as legislation.
Some analysts also suggest the Clarity Act's failure may benefit established exchanges. Hogan noted that delays in legislative processing could maintain regulatory barriers for existing operators like Coinbase and Kraken, limiting competition from new entrants. Brado emphasized that only Congress can establish a comprehensive and sustainable regulatory framework.
Korean Source
This article is an English localization of a Korean-language crypto news report. Original headline: 美 클래리티 법안 처리 무산에 SEC·CFTC 규제 주도…업계 "법적 불확실성 여전"