CNBC Investment Committee Holds Off on Selling as September Approaches

Major Wall Street desks have shifted to defensive positions ahead of September, while the CNBC Investment Committee moved in the opposite direction. All four committee members confirmed they have no plans to sell.
This divergence emerged after markets closed at a record high for the year on August 27, as September typically marks the calendar's weakest month.
Scott Rubner, head of equity and equity derivatives strategies at Citadel Securities with a Goldman Sachs background, highlighted three points in a memo dated August 31. Companies have approved buybacks of over $110 billion in shares through August, but these will quiet down starting September 12.
Rubner's data shows September has the weakest buying pressure of any month, with downside accumulation at only half its usual level. The VIX closed at 14.4 on August 14, marking the second-lowest level since December 2025.
Other desks followed suit: JPMorgan Trading shifted to neutral, while Wells Fargo adopted a cautious stance due to concerns over AI investment peaks. Just weeks ago, JPMorgan had raised its S&P outlook amid weakening hedge demand.
The committee's rationale for holding off on selling stems from the current quarter's momentum declining by double digits, though quality metrics rose 1.5%. Rubner noted markets have a buffer and aren't yet turning bearish. He avoids monthly timing, viewing every dip as an opportunity to increase positions in value stocks, which outperformed growth stocks by 14% this year.
He identifies himself as a long-term investor rather than a tactical trader, increasing exposure during market weakness. Momentum peaked on June 22 before falling 13.7%, a cycle he says has already occurred. Timing trades based on calendars, he argues, only increases tax burdens.
The committee explained its portfolio adjustments as September approaches. Historical data shows S&P 500's average September return since 1950 is -0.6%, with gains in 34 of 75 years. Labor Department reports also indicate resilience, with July job openings at 7.3 million.
Bitcoin (BTC) faced similar pressure, trading near $77,130 on Tuesday and falling over 2% in 24 hours. Both markets are experiencing September's historical weakness pattern.
Korean Source
This article is an English localization of a Korean-language crypto news report. Original headline: 9월 투자위원 4인…매도 없는 이유