KOSUNI CRYPTO
Korea's Crypto Pulse, in English
$BTC $ETH $XRP $SOL $DOGE
Market Analysis
Bearish

Cryptocurrency Gains Fail to Benefit Shareholders

Published September 26, 2026 12:55 PM · 14 views $BTC $ETH $SOL $HYPE
Cryptocurrency Gains Fail to Benefit Shareholders

Kaiko Research analyst Thomas Probst analyzed in a report released on September 2, 2026, that digital asset treasury firms (DATs) do not fully pass on the performance of their held cryptocurrencies to shareholders. Strategy (MSTR), which positioned itself around Bitcoin (BTC) accumulation, sold approximately 7,000 BTC over the summer, shaking market confidence in its 'permanent buyer' reputation.

DAT models expanded rapidly during 2024 and 2025, initially focusing on Bitcoin but later diversifying into Ethereum (ETH), Solana (SOL), and Hyperliquid (HYPE). Support for DATs came from increased spot liquidity, regulatory-compliant custody services, growth in derivatives markets, and improved accounting standards. However, reserves are meant to preserve capital, mitigate cash flow volatility, and absorb shocks—differing significantly from traditional reserve assets like cash or gold due to the high volatility and liquidity risks of digital assets.

This limitation became evident early in 2026. While the SPX index rose 11.33% over the first eight months, Strategy, Bitmain Emerging Technologies (BMNR), and Hyperion DeFi (HYPD) recorded returns of -19.78%, -23.92%, and -12.57%, respectively. Shareholders bore cryptocurrency market volatility without reaping stock market gains.

Strategy held 845,050 BTC as the largest corporate holder. The company maintained a premium over net asset value (NAV) by promising indefinite Bitcoin accumulation with no sales. This strategy involved issuing new shares to increase per-share Bitcoin holdings. However, after signaling active balance sheet management in May 2026, Strategy sold 32 BTC for approximately $250,000 in early June, followed by additional sales of about 1,363 BTC at month-end, 2,225 BTC early July, and 3,328 BTC mid-August. Proceeds were allocated to preferred dividends, dollar reserve expansion, and security repurchases.

According to Kaiko Research, while the total sales volume was small compared to holdings, the market signal was significant. The shift from a long-term accumulation strategy to active crypto trading based on funding costs and cash needs altered investor perception. Bitcoin dropped from around $73,000 to $60,000 within a week of the first sale announcement.

Strategy's 30-day volatility averaged 50-100%, far exceeding Bitcoin's 20-54% and SPX's 10-18%. Correlation with Bitcoin since April remained at 0.6-0.75, indicating Strategy does not provide independent stock market exposure or sufficient portfolio diversification benefits.

Bitmain shifted to an Ethereum-focused strategy in mid-2025 and became the largest ETH holder among firms. Its stock correlation with Ethereum stayed around 0.5-0.7 during 2026, reflecting that its price followed holdings but also incorporated additional risks from operations and funding.

Hyperion DeFi presents a more extreme case. Originally an eye care technology company, it transitioned in June 2025 to holding Hyperliquid (HYPE), the native token of the Hyperliquid blockchain, as its primary asset. Holdings surpassed 2 million HYPE tokens with token prices at around $82 on September 2, 2026. While HYPE rose approximately 234.2% in 2026, Hyperion's stock fluctuated near year-start levels with a slight decline. Their 30-day correlation averaged 0.1-0.7 (mean ~0.4), meaning investors choosing Hyperion for exposure to HYPE gains did not capture the underlying asset's rise.

Hyperion’s case isn't universal. Companies like PURR, a Nasdaq-listed stock linked to Hyperliquid Strategies, may achieve different results based on capital structure and management style. Ultimately, DAT value depends not only on token prices but also on funding costs, share dilution, debt and dividend burdens, and management's capital allocation ability.

Probst concluded that DAT stocks should not be viewed as simple substitutes for spot cryptocurrency holdings. Strategy's Bitcoin sales demonstrate that accumulation strategies can shift in response to cash needs and market conditions. Investors must assess both the potential upside of underlying assets and the 'corporate financial risk' and how it translates into shareholder returns.

Korean Source

This article is an English localization of a Korean-language crypto news report. Original headline: "암호화폐 올라도 주주는 웃지 못했다"…카이코 리서치, DAT 구조적 한계 진단