DeFi Should Be Regulated by Four Categories Based on Control and Intermediation

A senior financial regulator has proposed dividing decentralized finance (DeFi) services into four categories based on control and intermediation aspects, arguing that regulation should be tailored by functionality and type.
The proposal comes from a research paper published in August by Cho Jae-woo, a senior examiner at the Financial Supervisory Service (FSS), titled "Responsibility Structure of Decentralized Finance: Regulation Based on Control and Intermediation." The paper is not an official FSS position but represents the author's personal view.
The author categorizes the DeFi market into four zones: high-control/high-intermediation, low-control/high-intermediation, high-control/low-intermediation, and low-control/low-intermediation. Control refers to technical interventions that can alter, halt, block, or circumvent transactions, while intermediation involves contractual relationships with users, transaction routing design, order matching, execution, and fee collection.
In the high-control/high-intermediation zone, where user assets are held and transactions organized, existing virtual asset business regulations could be strengthened. Measures such as segregated asset custody, internal controls, market surveillance, and conflict-of-interest prevention—similar to traditional finance regulation—could apply.
For low-control/high-intermediation services that organize transactions through interfaces, token listings, and recommendations but don't hold user assets, the focus should be on front-end operator regulation. Requirements could include disclosing token listing criteria, transaction support standards, and scam warnings.
In high-control/low-intermediation areas where transactions aren't organized but price formation, collateral valuation, and risk allocation still significantly impact markets, infrastructure providers' responsibilities may need scrutiny. Transparency measures like security audits, core parameter disclosure, and vulnerability response systems could be implemented.
For low-control/low-intermediation pure protocols—where direct traditional regulation is difficult—the focus should shift to individual actor accountability for fraud or market manipulation rather than broad regulatory imposition.
The paper also emphasizes the need for on-chain supervision and public disclosure, along with implementing a "safe harbor" framework. A safe harbor allows entities meeting specific legal criteria to avoid liability or regulation.
Given DeFi's anonymous, cross-border smart contract transactions, traditional monitoring methods struggle to identify risks in real time. The author suggests leveraging on-chain data through high-dimensional analytics systems to improve regulatory timeliness and effectiveness. Specific metrics like management keys, upgrade permissions, emergency stop capabilities, multi-sig configurations, and decision-making criteria should be publicly disclosed for transparency.
For fully decentralized services, the paper proposes conditional safe harbors—requiring relinquishment of management keys, non-exclusive front-end control, and infrastructure decentralization—to objectively verify compliance with decentralization claims.
The author concludes that while DeFi enables blockchain-based decentralization, it cannot be exempt from regulation under the guise of decentralization. "Excluding DeFi from regulatory oversight or tolerating market chaos and user harm based on decentralization arguments is unfair," he states. He calls for a second-stage legislative framework to design functional-type regulation for sustainable DeFi ecosystem growth.
Korean Source
This article is an English localization of a Korean-language crypto news report. Original headline: "디파이, 4가지 영역으로 나눠 규제해야"