Digital Asset ETFs Should Start with Spot Products Before Full Implementation

On October 10, Lim Seung-jin, a researcher at F&Guide, presented at the 'Digital Asset Financial Innovation Cases and Response Strategies' seminar held at Post Tower in Yeouido, Seoul. He emphasized that introducing digital asset ETFs should begin with simple spot ETFs to gradually verify market infrastructure and risk management systems.
Lim noted that the starting point for digital asset ETF implementation is clarifying the legal status of digital assets, as current laws do not include them in the definition of underlying assets, leaving insufficient grounds for issuing spot ETFs. He also stated that derivatives face similar issues due to lacking clear legal foundations for underlying assets.
After establishing legal frameworks, market infrastructure such as pricing mechanisms, custody, and subscription/redemption processes must be built. Lim stressed that simply being a registered virtual asset business operator does not automatically qualify an exchange as ETF-eligible, requiring concrete criteria on price reliability, market structure, and information requirements.
He warned against relying solely on single-exchange prices due to vulnerability to trading disruptions and price distortions, advocating for multi-exchange pricing with volume considerations. Information-sharing mechanisms between spot and ETF markets were also highlighted as essential to maintain market integrity.
Custody of digital assets was identified as a key challenge, requiring separation of private keys and withdrawal rights from traditional securities custody standards. Lim suggested involving banks or trust entities while ensuring proper licensing for specialized custodians.
Lim further explained that ETF pricing must align with underlying asset values to prevent discrepancies during trading. Digital assets' 24-hour trading nature necessitates measures to handle overnight price fluctuations and ensure liquidity, including reviewing price limits to avoid gaps between ETF and spot prices.
He proposed a phased approach: start with simple spot ETFs, validate infrastructure stability, then expand to multi-asset strategies and staking-based products. For staking, he noted the trade-off between higher rewards and reduced liquidity, suggesting liquid staking tokens (LSTs) as a solution but cautioning about potential price disadvantages during market stress.
Lim concluded that success depends not on how many products are added but on gradually advancing based on validated operational experience and current scale, requiring both legal recognition of digital assets and clear regulatory frameworks for custody and investor protection.
Korean Source
This article is an English localization of a Korean-language crypto news report. Original headline: "가상자산 ETF, 현물부터 단계적 도입해야"