Ethereum's EIP-8363 Proposal Withdrawn from 'Hegota' Upgrade After Debate

Ethereum's plan to reduce issuance with EIP-8363 has been removed from consideration as a candidate for the upcoming network upgrade 'Hegota.' The decision reflects that proposals concerning issuance policy should be discussed through separate governance processes rather than being included in standard fork implementations.
On October 1 (local time), Jerome de Tissey, Ethereum France representative, announced on X (formerly Twitter) that EIP-8363 would be withdrawn from the Hegota review list. The proposal had been under discussion during the Candidate For Implementation (CFI) process for selecting candidates for the Hegota upgrade.
During CFI discussions, industry stakeholders and core developers argued that major monetary policy issues like ETH issuance should undergo separate governance procedures. De Tissey agreed with this perspective and stated that future Ethereum issuance policy matters would be handled through dedicated processes.
EIP-8363 was proposed by the Ethereum Foundation's Justin Drake on August 4, suggesting a 'burn-based emission reduction' mechanism where more ETH would be burned from staking rewards as staked ETH increases. The proposal designed that when staked ETH reaches approximately half of total supply (60.25 million ETH), the burn rate would reach 100%. Implementation would occur gradually over about 18 months.
The proposal sparked significant debate, with over 200 comments on Ethereum Magicians forum, where de Tissey described it as one of the most discussed proposals in forum history. Key concerns centered around how rising staking ratios might affect Ethereum's network and ETH's economic structure.
De Tissey noted that while EIP-8363 was withdrawn, concerns about rising staking ratios affecting network security, neutrality, and ETH's role as currency remain. He stated these issues would be reorganized into five categories for further discussion: security, validator composition, solo staker impact, and others.
Market reactions were mixed. George Chalom, CEO of ETH-holding company Sharpling, opposed EIP-8363 in August, arguing it could harm decentralized finance (DeFi). Stanislav Kulechov, founder of Aave, also previously stated the proposal could be harmful to Ethereum.
Following the withdrawal announcement, Kulechov cited de Tissey's post with a positive response, supporting the separation of issuance policy discussions into dedicated procedures.
If implemented, EIP-8363 would have reduced annual staking yields from approximately 2.6% to 1.2%, based on August data showing about 34% of total ETH supply was staked. The reduction in staking rewards could directly affect validator incentives and network operations, contributing to the divided opinions on the proposal.
Meanwhile, Ethereum developers are finalizing details for Hegota, the next phase after Glammaster. Vitalik Buterin recently suggested Hegota might be the last general fork maintaining technical prerequisites from 2015 in his blog post.
The withdrawal of EIP-8363 means Ethereum's network upgrades and monetary policy discussions will proceed separately. Future matters affecting ETH issuance and staking rewards are expected to undergo dedicated governance procedures rather than being bundled with upgrade implementations.
Korean Source
This article is an English localization of a Korean-language crypto news report. Original headline: 이더리움 발행량 감축안, 결국 '헤고타' 후보서 철회…별도 절차로