Fidelity's Timmer Says Investment Clock Has Moved Past Midnight... Similar to 2018 and 2022 Downturns

Fidelity's Jureen Timmer stated that the investment clock has moved "past midnight," emphasizing that tightening financial conditions are starting to curb profit-based gains. He identified 2018 and 2022 as the last two cycles where similar structures emerged.
Fidelity's investment clock compares financial conditions against earnings growth rates. Current measurements show slight tightening, though analysts forecast a 30.6% Q3 earnings growth rate for the S&P 500 according to LSEG data.
Why is mild tightening starting to impact now? Timmer used chart data through October 11 on X (formerly Twitter) to illustrate this metric.
The horizontal axis scores financial conditions relative to a 52-week history, with positive values indicating more tightening than usual. The black trajectory tracking the market ends just right of zero, as shown in his post.
Meanwhile, U.S. Treasury yields have risen alongside this shift. The 10-year yield climbed to 5.34% on October 1, reaching its highest level since early 2002. The Federal Reserve raised rates in September—the first increase since 2023—and CME's FedWatch tool estimated an 18% probability of a rate hike in October as of October 8.
Can 30% earnings growth overcome the 2022 precedent? In 2022, earnings continued rising while valuations declined. Yardeni Research noted that the multiple investors paid for earnings dropped by 30%, yet future earnings grew by 6.2%. The S&P 500 fell 25.4% from January 3 to October 12, with declining multiples driving the decline.
Similarly, in 2018, a market letter analyzed a 19.3% drop from September 20 high to December 24 low. Timmer referenced these parallels in Fidelity's September note but noted that this time, around 30% earnings growth could serve as a stronger buffer.
The current test will unfold through the Federal Reserve decision on October 28 and the earnings season. The S&P 500 closed at an all-time high above 7,800 points on October 6, Reuters reported.
With 10-year yields exceeding 5% early in October, it may become critical for earnings growth to outpace valuation declines.
Korean Source
This article is an English localization of a Korean-language crypto news report. Original headline: 티머, 투자 시계 ‘자정 지나’ 구간…2018·2022 하락 전과 유사