Gemini Avoids Liability in Earn Program Collapse Dispute

Gemini ($GEMI) has avoided being held responsible for misleading users or failing to conduct adequate due diligence on its main lending partner, Genesis Global Capital (Genesis), in the arbitration case concerning the collapse of its Earn program. According to CNBC, the arbitrator ruled on August 12 that there was insufficient evidence Gemini provided false explanations to Earn users or neglected proper due diligence regarding Genesis.
The claim, filed by an Earn user at the end of 2024, challenged Gemini's explanations and management responsibilities. However, the arbitrator determined that for emotional distress claims to hold, there must be proof of breach of duty, emotional harm, causation, and substantiating circumstances. The ruling noted that the claimant failed to prove actual or perceived threats to physical safety.
This decision narrows Gemini's legal responsibility in individual user arbitration cases related to Earn, which was launched in 2021. Earn allowed users to earn up to 7.4% annually by lending their virtual assets. Gemini loaned user assets to institutional borrowers, with Genesis serving as a key intermediary.
The issue escalated in November 2022 when Genesis halted new loans and repayments due to liquidity pressures amid market downturns, causing Gemini to stop Earn withdrawals. At that time, over 300,000 users were enrolled in Earn.
Following the withdrawal halt, some users filed legal actions against Gemini. In 2024, New York State prosecutors announced a $50 million (approximately 68.9 billion KRW) settlement where Gemini admitted to misleading investors about Earn risks, ensuring all unrecovered assets would be returned to Earn investors. As part of the agreement, Gemini was prohibited from operating its virtual asset lending program in New York.
This arbitration ruling is separate from the New York State settlement and pertains specifically to a claim filed by an individual user seeking damages. In February 2024, Gemini announced it had reached a principle agreement with Genesis during Genesis' bankruptcy proceedings. By May 2024, Earn users received $218 million (approximately 3.19 trillion KRW) in virtual assets at spot value, representing 97% of what Genesis owed to Earn users—a sum exceeding the amount by $1 billion compared to when Genesis halted withdrawals in 2022.
While this ruling absolves Gemini from liability for this specific arbitration claim, the company's disputes over Earn are not fully resolved. CNBC reported that more than ten pending cases involving Earn users against Gemini remain as of early August.
Korean Source
This article is an English localization of a Korean-language crypto news report. Original headline: 제미니 언 책임 인정 안 돼, 오도 증거 부족 판단