Gold ETFs Show Divergent Returns Amid Currency Fluctuations

Gold and silver prices rebounded, leading to a quick recovery in related exchange-traded funds (ETFs). However, despite similar investments in precious metals, monthly returns for different products diverged by about 3 percentage points. The strength of the Korean won caused hedged futures ETFs to outperform unhedged physical metal ETFs.
According to the Korea Exchange, KODEX Gold Futures (H) rose 8.41% in August, while ACE KRX Gold Physical gained 5.16% and TIGER KRX Gold Physical increased by 5.22%. Hedged gold futures ETFs generated approximately 3.2 percentage points higher returns than domestic physical metal ETFs.
A similar trend was observed in silver. KODEX Silver Futures (H) surged 13.19% over the month, compared to TIGER Silver Active at 10.46% and 1Q Silver Active at 9.47%. Silver showed stronger upward momentum than gold.
The key factor separating returns was the won-dollar exchange rate. As international gold and silver prices rose, the won also strengthened. Unhedged products saw lower won-denominated returns due to falling won-dollar rates despite rising global prices.
Hedged ETFs mitigate this currency impact using forward contracts. In periods where both gold/silver prices and won strength rise simultaneously, hedged ETFs gain an advantage. Conversely, if gold rises with won weakness, unhedged products can benefit from both price gains and currency appreciation.
However, the return gap cannot be solely attributed to hedging effects. KODEX Gold Futures (H) tracks international futures, while ACE and TIGER gold physical ETFs follow domestic prices. Silver ETFs also differ in investment focus between futures and physical assets. Price differences between spot and futures, rollover costs, and price discrepancies also affect returns.
Interest rates significantly influence gold prices. Gold does not pay interest like bonds or deposits. Rising rates increase the opportunity cost of holding gold, while falling rates reduce this burden and often support higher prices. Market participants closely monitor real interest rates (nominal rates minus inflation), as lower or negative real rates can boost gold's relative appeal.
Gold and dollar prices typically move inversely. As international gold is priced in dollars, a weaker dollar makes gold relatively cheaper for investors using other currencies like euro or yen, potentially increasing demand and price. However, the 'rate cut = higher gold' relationship isn't always consistent. During financial crises or geopolitical tensions, both gold and dollars can rise simultaneously as safe-haven assets.
Gold investment is generally favorable during periods of falling interest rates, declining real rates, and dollar weakness. Investors should also watch for Fed policy shifts toward easing after tightening cycles, especially amid economic slowdowns, market volatility, or heightened geopolitical risks when using gold as a portfolio hedge.
Conversely, rising inflation leading to higher Fed rates and stronger dollars can pressure gold prices. Recent price surges have prompted caution against chasing gains, with KODEX Gold Futures (H) dropping 3.19% and KODEX Silver Futures (H) falling 3.82% on August 31.
Future gold direction depends on U.S. consumer inflation data, employment reports, Fed rate expectations, real yields on U.S. Treasury bonds, and the dollar index. A combination of slowing economic growth, rising rate cut expectations, declining real rates, and weakening dollars would likely create favorable conditions for gold.
Investment choice should align with currency outlooks. For expected gold price increases alongside won strength, hedged ETFs are preferable. For anticipated gold rises with won weakness, unhedged products may be considered. Investors seeking lower volatility might focus on gold, while those willing to accept higher volatility for stronger upside potential could consider silver.
A fund manager noted: 'Gold prices move in tandem with U.S. interest rates, dollar movements, and won-dollar exchange rates. Simply expecting gold prices to rise without considering these factors is unwise.' They advised domestic ETF investors to check whether products include '(H)' for hedging and whether they track spot or futures.
Korean Source
This article is an English localization of a Korean-language crypto news report. Original headline: "금 ETF 샀는데 누구는 8%, 나는 5%"…수익률 벌어진 이유