Insider Selling in Refining Sector Hits Record High as Banks Skip Buying

Executives at refining firms Par Pacific (Par Pacific) and PBF Energy have sold shares following annual gains of 149% and 210%, respectively. Meanwhile, insider buying in the financial sector has dropped to its lowest level in 23 years.
Insider transactions are publicly disclosed but difficult to interpret. Ben Silverman, head of research at VerityData, noted that while such data can be useful for individual companies, it has limitations when applied across entire sectors.
VerityData charts show insider selling-to-buying ratios in the energy sector at approximately 1.4, above the long-term average of 1.0 and higher than the broader market's 1.2. The financial sector saw the highest ratio among all industries during Q3, with a level about 2.1 times its long-term average.
Par Pacific and PBF are mid-sized refiners trading near all-time highs, according to Wall Street Journal columnist Spencer Jakab. PBF reported a quarterly adjusted profit of $6.22 per share in Q2, reversing last year's loss. Jakab noted that gasoline refining prices recently surpassed $200 per barrel, with G7 nations agreeing to release 100 million barrels from emergency reserves.
Jakab believes gasoline prices are unlikely to maintain current levels and points out that industry veterans better understand sector limits than investors. He also cautioned that executives might misjudge investor sentiment toward their industries.
While financial insiders' buying has declined, VerityData clarified that selling volumes haven't increased—only reduced buying has raised the ratio. Major banks Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley, and JPMorgan Chase will report earnings next week amid rising US Treasury yields above 5%, with per-share profits at four times their level from a decade ago.
However, Jakab highlighted pressures outside banking including private credit challenges, consumer weakness, and record borrowing by AI firms. In contrast, the consumer staples sector showed the lowest insider buying ratio at half its long-term average, with companies like Altria, Tyson Foods, and Celsius Holdings seeing executives buy shares recently.
Investors can track these transactions through SEC Form 4 filings, which also reveal insider selling by Nvidia—a trend visible as Nasdaq reaches all-time highs. This data may indicate how much confidence insiders have in current market valuations.
Korean Source
This article is an English localization of a Korean-language crypto news report. Original headline: 인사이더 정유사 매도…은행은 건너뛰다, 투자자 어찌해야 하나?