IPO on Blockchain Still IPO: Tokenization Doesn't Change Fundamentals

A company issues shares through an initial public offering (IPO). Investors apply and receive allocated shares in digital wallets, with ownership recorded on a blockchain. Is this an IPO or an initial coin offering (ICO)? The answer is clear: if a company legally offers new shares for the first time, using blockchain doesn't change its essence as an IPO. Just as electronic securities didn't alter the nature of stock when replacing paper certificates, tokenization doesn't determine the rights investors acquire.
The more important question is what can be done with these on-chain shares. The significance of on-chain IPOs lies after issuance, not in the application process. For example, if a company offers 1 million new shares at $10 each, an investor who applies and receives full allocation for $1,000 would receive 100 tokens representing one share each. Once fully subscribed, the company raises $10 million. Investor rights like voting and dividends are determined by share type, corporate charter, and offering terms—not by tokenization.
Labeling this as an ICO misses the point. While ICOs encompass various token sales with different rights structures—including those that qualify as securities—terminology shouldn't overshadow economic substance. The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) clarified in January 2024 that the format of security issuance or blockchain recording doesn't change federal securities law applicability.
A key distinction must be made: tokenizing existing shares versus issuing new shares for capital raising. If a third party tokenizes already-traded shares, no new funds reach the company. Whether token holders are direct shareholders, hold indirect rights, or own price-linked products depends on structure. A company's name attached to tokens doesn't guarantee identical shareholder rights.
Current tokenization market examples shouldn't be immediately equated with on-chain IPOs. However, platforms like OnTempo Finance recently enabled Ethereum-based MoPo lending markets to use tokenized ETF products SPYon and QQQon as collateral in February 2024. Solana-based Camino also supports xStocks for borrowing USDC while holding assets.
These cases connect existing assets to other financial services. If this extends to new share issuance, investors receiving share tokens could later pledge them in lending markets without selling shares—expanding capital access. While stock-backed loans have existed before, blockchain can reduce costs and procedures by linking ownership transfers, payments, and collateral settings.
However, easier connections don't necessarily mean reduced risk. More convenient collateralized borrowing may lead to increased leverage on the same assets. Price differences and liquidity gaps could widen if tokens trade while traditional markets are closed, as Camino notes regarding market timing discrepancies, pricing information, liquidity, and forced liquidation risks.
Tokenized IPO shares aren't automatically eligible for collateral or global trading just because they're tokenized. They must meet transfer restrictions, investor qualifications, trading rules, and lending market collateral requirements. The competitive edge of on-chain finance lies in both speed of connection and the legal framework supporting rights and responsibilities behind those connections.
For Korea, policy goals shouldn't end at enabling tokenized securities issuance. Without linking issuance to trading, payment, and collateral use, utility for companies and investors remains limited. Companies need better capital-raising paths beyond traditional methods; investors require reliable transactions, clear rights exercise, and asset utilization options. This requires legal recognition of ownership records, proper trading markets, settlement mechanisms, and collateral rights execution.
Not all IPOs will move to blockchain immediately. Companies and investors will weigh technology's novelty against cost and convenience. Adoption gains traction when capital raising improves, transactions become easier, and rights are clearly protected. While an on-chain IPO remains an IPO, how shares are traded, paid for, and used as collateral could reshape capital market competition.
Korean Source
This article is an English localization of a Korean-language crypto news report. Original headline: [권성민 칼럼] IPO가 온체인으로 가면 ICO가 되는가