KOSUNI CRYPTO
Korea's Crypto Pulse, in English
$BTC $ETH $XRP $SOL $DOGE
Market Analysis
Neutral

KOSPI PER Halved Amid Mixed Analyst Views on Valuation

Published October 2, 2026 6:51 AM · 5 views
KOSPI PER Halved Amid Mixed Analyst Views on Valuation

KOSPI's price-to-earnings ratio (PER) has fallen to nearly half of its long-term average, but analysts warn that it should not be immediately interpreted as an undervaluation signal. While corporate profit estimates remain high, stock prices have declined significantly, leading the market to question the sustainability of earnings and adjust valuations accordingly.

According to financial data provider F&G Guide, the consensus estimate for Q3 operating profits of KOSPI-listed companies totaled 270.8894 trillion won, a 230.97% year-on-year increase. The estimate has even risen by 0.16% over the past three months.

Meanwhile, the KOSPI index fell 19.33% during the same period. With profit forecasts unchanged but stock prices plummeting, the 12-month forward PER dropped from 7.69 times to 5.38 times. This is half of the recent 10-year average of 10.25 times.

However, securities analysts argue that a lower PER alone does not necessarily indicate increased price attractiveness. Shinhan Investment Securities analyst No Dong-gil stated, "It's difficult to immediately interpret the current low PER as undervaluation." He noted that semiconductor giants' profit estimates have surged, significantly boosting earnings per share (EPS), which could create a misleading impression if compared using historical metrics.

No emphasized that the market's key question is whether profits can be sustained and what valuation should be applied to those profits. "Only with confidence in the sustainability of high profits can valuations rebound," he explained.

Post-earnings performance also significantly impacts stock movements. Shinhan Investment analyzed 1,274 earnings reports from 98 large companies between Q1 2023 and Q2 2024. It found that EPS upward revisions after an earnings surprise—not the surprise itself—were more influential on stock returns.

Companies that exceeded consensus by over 5% in operating profit and saw a 2% or higher upward revision to their 12-month forward EPS within four weeks achieved an outperformance of 3.33 percentage points above the market. Those with minimal EPS changes (within ±2%) showed little outperformance, while those with downward revisions of over 2% underperformed by 2.73 percentage points.

As a result, for Q4 investment strategies, analysts suggest focusing more on next year's profit forecast changes than short-term results. No recommended adjusting portfolios in November based on shifts in next year's earnings outlook following the release of Q3 results in October.

For sectors with high visibility into 2025 profits, semiconductors were highlighted. Demand for DRAM bits is expected to grow by 25.1% annually through 2027, outpacing supply growth of 24.6%, suggesting continued supply shortages until 2028.

In non-semiconductor sectors, shipbuilding and power equipment were prioritized due to high conversion potential from existing order backlogs into next year's revenue and profits. Shipbuilders are expected to benefit from higher-margin sales recognition of new vessels and cost improvements, while power equipment firms will be driven by capacity expansion and improved profitability.

Cosmetics was identified as a potential earnings growth candidate. With cosmetics exports rising 44.3% year-on-year in July and August, analysts recommend selecting companies where this export surge translates into tangible revenue and profit improvements for next year.

In conclusion, the key to Q4 market performance lies not in the reduced PER itself but in the direction of next year's earnings forecasts. Analysts advise seeking out stocks with upward revisions to profit estimates rather than chasing already-rising sectors.

Korean Source

This article is an English localization of a Korean-language crypto news report. Original headline: 코스피 PER 반토막…증권가가 '저가 매수' 경계한 이유