Ledger Hardware Wallet Trust Shaken by Malicious Component Scandal

Blockchain media CoinTelegraph reported on April 14 (local time) that a malicious component was discovered embedded in Ledger hardware wallets, which had stolen users' recovery phrases and transmitted them via mobile networks.
The incident involved devices sold through authorized resellers CryptoBilis in Indonesia, Malaysia, and the Philippines. Ledger confirmed on April 10 that it identified an unauthorized malicious component in one affected device. The component collected users' recovery phrases and sent them over mobile networks.
Hardware wallets are designed to store private keys offline to reduce exposure to online attacks. However, as their global distribution networks expand, the risk of supply chain tampering has increased.
Security expert Joe Grand, who developed methods for extracting data from memory chips in Trezor and KeepKey wallets, stated that it is practically impossible for average users to detect sophisticated tampering. He noted that even tech-savvy individuals do not inspect devices one by one, making it extremely difficult to explain how to verify hardware.
Crypto analyst Mati Greenspan, who has been in the industry since 2013 but never used a hardware wallet, pointed out that purchasing a hardware wallet creates a new chain of trust from manufacturer through resellers and previous handlers.
Nick Neuman, CEO of Bitcoin security firm Casa, acknowledged it is impossible to completely avoid third-party trust. He advised spreading risk across multiple providers rather than relying on a single intermediary.
Trezor, Ledger's competitor, stated that its devices undergo authenticity checks and only accept signed firmware. However, the company admitted that such measures cannot prevent physical tampering. Trezor noted that this malicious component operated by intercepting screen information without modifying firmware, and that it had not observed similar attacks on its devices. On April 13, Trezor announced plans to reduce the number of resellers as a preventive measure.
Experts have suggested transparent cases where internal components are visible or anti-tampering enclosures requiring attackers to recreate entire casings. However, these designs only make supply chain attacks more difficult without eliminating the risk entirely.
Korean Source
This article is an English localization of a Korean-language crypto news report. Original headline: 렛저 사태에 신뢰 '흔들'… 암호화폐 하드웨어 지갑, 믿을 수 있나?