KOSUNI CRYPTO
Korea's Crypto Pulse, in English
$BTC $ETH $XRP $SOL $DOGE
News
Neutral

Lightning Network Payment Cancellation Misreported as 'Completed', Risking Product Delivery

Published September 25, 2026 10:01 AM · 13 views $BTC
Lightning Network Payment Cancellation Misreported as 'Completed', Risking Product Delivery

A flaw has been disclosed in the Lightning Network where a canceled Bitcoin (BTC) payment may be recorded as 'settled' within the recipient node's database. If a seller mistakenly believes an invoice status is correct, they could provide goods or credits without receiving payment. Lightning Labs announced the issue on January 21 with a security notice rating it 'T1·High'. The problem arises when an HTLC (Hashed Timelock Contract) used in payments is canceled on the network and returned to the sender, but the invoice remains marked as 'settled' in the recipient's database. This occurs due to a combination of flaws in Taproot Assets implementation tapd and Lightning Network node software lnd. Specifically, tapd misidentified HTLCs with user-defined records as asset payments, while lnd updated the invoice status to 'settled' even after canceling the HTLC on the network.

The issue was triggered when sender implementations attached experimental endorsement TLV to standard Bitcoin payments. If a recipient's Taproot Assets invoice interceptor is active and processes this record as an asset payment, the flaw activates. Attackers did not need direct access to a seller's payment channel; if the interceptor was enabled on the receiving node and the sender's implementation set the problematic TLV, the flaw could occur even without open asset channels. However, it does not result in funds disappearing from senders' wallets—HTLCs were properly returned to senders. The risk lies in sellers providing goods or services based on a false 'completed' payment status.

Lightning Labs did not report any actual damage or loss cases. The core risk is mismatched payment processing and operational accounting, not fund theft. Affected versions include taproot assets v0.5.0 and below, lnd 0.18.4-beta through 0.18.5-beta, and Lightning Terminal v0.15.0-alpha and below. Fixed versions are taproot assets v0.5.1, lnd v0.19.0-beta, and Lightning Terminal v0.15.0-alpha. Taproot Assets' fix was deployed on February 12, 2025; lnd's accounting error was resolved in its v0.19.0-beta release on May 22, 2025; and Lightning Terminal fixes became available from v0.15.0-alpha onward.

Lightning Labs identified the issue through a field report on January 27, 2025, but the security notice was published over a year after the fixes were released. The flaw is not a consensus error in the Bitcoin blockchain but rather a discrepancy between network status and internal accounting in payment software. Sellers using Lightning for transactions should verify both invoice status and actual fund movement. Operators unable to update immediately can temporarily disable asset channels via --taproot-assets-mode=disable, though this setting requires verification based on channel usage.

Korean Source

This article is an English localization of a Korean-language crypto news report. Original headline: 라이트닝 결제 취소됐는데 ‘완료’ 기록…상품 제공 위험