MetaPlanet's 20% Stock Option Pool Controversy Sparks Debate

MetaPlanet (3350) is facing controversy over its executive stock option pool reaching 20% of company shares, with CEO David Bailey defending the compensation structure and Strive executives arguing the two firms cannot be compared.
David Bailey, Chairman and CEO of Nakamoto, posted on X that distributing 20% of company equity over five years to the team is 'not a crazy number' but rather 'low,' citing MetaPlanet's performance as justification. The controversy centers around MetaPlanet's 10th stock acquisition program introduced in December 2022, which tied the option pool size to a percentage of fully diluted shares—the total shares including potential conversions and exercises.
As MetaPlanet raised capital for Bitcoin purchases through multiple share issuances, the option pool grew from approximately 46 million shares to about 319 million shares. On August 18, the board fixed the fully diluted share count at 319.46 million, retaining an outstanding pool of around 273 million shares that critics have demanded be canceled.
While acknowledging past dilution issues in their previous structure, MetaPlanet's board opted to switch from a percentage-based system to a fixed number but did not eliminate the expanded option pool. Bailey argued MetaPlanet has been one of the world's best-performing stocks over two years, with shares rising 1300% since inception and increasing Bitcoin holdings by over 40x per share.
He also cited Strive ($MSTR) CEO Michael Saylor and Strive's Vibek Ramaswamy as examples of founders maintaining meaningful economic stakes. However, Matt Cole, CEO of Strive, countered that the two companies are incomparable, noting that Strive's 270.5 million shares were distributed to all shareholders pre-merger rather than as executive compensation. He clarified that Ramaswamy is not an officer or director at Strive and that no rights were assigned during his tenure.
Strive's stock-based compensation does not automatically expand with new share issuances, Cole explained, adding that his own confirmed economic stake remains under 1%. The company plans to allocate approximately $21 million annually over three years for team compensation based on Mercer's 50th percentile benchmark.
ZynxBTC of FalconEdge warned on X that justifying a $500 million payout for '30 people working 30 months' is unreasonable, emphasizing that the existing option pool remains despite recent changes. MetaPlanet shares closed at 244 yen on August 8, down about 17% over two trading days, while Bitcoin (BTC) remained relatively stable.
Korean Source
This article is an English localization of a Korean-language crypto news report. Original headline: 메타플래닛 20% 옵션 풀 논란…스트라이브 CEO “비교 불가”