Midterm Election Year Q4 Average Up 5.5%... Stoval Explains the Trend

CFRA Chief Investment Strategist Sam Stoval said that the fourth quarter returns in midterm election years average around 5.5%. He advised investors to continue holding top-performing stocks from the third quarter.
Speaking on Monday's CNBC 'The Exchange,' Stoval noted that stocks are under pressure, with the S&P 500 closing down 0.77% at 7,683.69 due to rising Treasury yields.
Historically, in midterm election years, the S&P 500 has seen an average quarterly return of about 5.5%, and there's a 75% probability of continued gains in Q4 if Q3 was positive. This year meets those conditions as the index rose more than 2% this quarter, with CNBC data showing it gained over 12% by 2026.
Stoval clarified that investors shouldn't assume this rally has pulled forward Q4 gains, stating that midterm election years' Q2 and Q3 typically underperform. Instead, he recommended holding top-performing Q3 stocks.
For sectors with weak Q3 performance, Stoval noted that investors would buy the worst-performing three sectors. He attributed leadership to financial strength, citing low net debt/EBITDA ratios as key drivers of outperformance amid rising rate concerns. Energy, healthcare, technology, and communication services led this group, while industrials, real estate, and utilities lagged.
Stoval highlighted that the technology sector alone accounts for nearly 40% of S&P 500 market capitalization, with communication services bringing it close to half. Rising oil prices have boosted confirmed fair values for Exxon and Chevron.
Rising interest rates and oil prices are weighing on stocks, with 10-year Treasury yields reaching a high of 5.23% on Friday—the highest since June 2007 according to Zacks. The host noted that yields were at 3.99% as of late February.
Stoval said even short-term market volatility could indicate inflation, interest rates, and oil prices remain concerns for 2026 markets. However, without immediate market relief, low-debt leadership may continue into Q4.
Korean Source
This article is an English localization of a Korean-language crypto news report. Original headline: 중간선거 해 4분기 평균 5.5% 상승…스토발, 상승 원인 해설