MSCI Faces Backlash Over Strategy's Inclusion Criteria for Bitcoin-Heavy Companies

Strategy (MSTR) has pushed back against MSCI's proposed classification of non-operational companies, reigniting a debate over the criteria for including Bitcoin (BTC)-holding listed companies in indices. The core issue is whether large Bitcoin holders should be categorized as operational businesses or asset-focused entities.
MSCI proposed new exclusion criteria in an August 2026 consultation document, which states that non-operational firms could be excluded from its global investable market indices if they fail to meet certain thresholds. The deadline for submissions is September 30, with a decision expected by October 16 or earlier. If approved, changes would take effect in the November 2026 index review.
The proposal uses a two-tier system: first assessing whether operating assets exceed half of total assets; if not, five additional metrics—operating asset intensity, cost intensity, cash flow, fair value change, and capital dependency—are applied. A firm must fail four out of these five criteria to be deemed non-eligible for inclusion.
MSCI stated that current index constituents will have a buffer period: they won't be removed immediately for failing once but only after two consecutive failures. The company claims this approach reduces index volatility, citing simulations based on May 2026 data showing Strategy, MetaPlanet (3350), and Yellow Cake plc as potential exclusions, while Shaping Gaming ($SBET), Center Laboratories, and Lydia Holding were placed under watch.
Strategy called the proposal 'discriminatory, arbitrary, and wrong,' noting it reclassified Bitcoin activities into a separate business segment starting from Q2 2026. The company also reported purchasing an additional 4,603 BTC by August 31, 2026, emphasizing its view that Bitcoin holdings are part of core operations rather than passive investments.
While MSCI's criteria focus on asset composition and financial ratios to distinguish operational from non-operational entities, Strategy argues it has a software business and treats Bitcoin as an operating segment. This divergence between the company’s self-description and MSCI’s classification method highlights ongoing tension in how such firms are categorized.
The debate is not new: MSCI previously considered excluding digital asset financial companies in 2025 but postponed action until January 2026, when it announced broader review plans. This proposal targets non-operational entities broadly rather than specific Bitcoin-holding firms.
Market implications center on passive fund flows. Index-tracking funds must hold a fixed proportion of index constituents, so exclusion could reduce the investor base for such stocks. Analysts previously estimated that if Strategy were removed from MSCI indices, it might trigger up to $2.8 billion in passive selling pressure—a figure some suggest could rise to $8.8 billion across multiple indices.
MSCI will accept market feedback until September 30 before announcing a decision by October 16 or earlier. If approved, changes would apply starting with the November 2026 index review.
Korean Source
This article is an English localization of a Korean-language crypto news report. Original headline: 엠에스시아이, 스트레티지 편출 여부 10월 결론