Peter Schiff Criticizes MicroStrategy's Bitcoin Strategy as ROI Drops to -3.7%

Peter Schiff, a gold bullion advocate and Bitcoin critic, has publicly criticized Michael Saylor's Bitcoin acquisition strategy. According to blockchain media U.Today, on October 12 (local time), Schiff pointed out that MicroStrategy's Bitcoin return since the beginning of the year stands at -3.7% following Saylor's recent announcement of additional Bitcoin purchases.
In a post on X (formerly Twitter), Schiff stated, "According to the metrics you've presented, 2026 has been a failure so far." He argued that the Bitcoin return metric emphasized by Saylor as a key performance indicator for the company actually highlights limitations in the acquisition strategy. The Bitcoin return metric measures changes in MicroStrategy's Bitcoin holdings relative to diluted shares and is not a direct measure of the company's stock price or investment returns on its Bitcoin holdings.
Despite criticism, MicroStrategy continues its Bitcoin acquisitions. Saylor recently purchased an additional 250 Bitcoins and repurchased $192 million (approximately 267 billion KRW) in preferred shares. The Bitcoin purchase involved approximately $21.5 million (about 28.7 billion KRW), with an average acquisition price of $86,194 per BTC.
As of October 11, MicroStrategy holds a total of 848,250 BTC, with total purchase costs amounting to approximately $64 billion and an average acquisition price of $75,444 per BTC. The company also maintains about $5.5 billion (approximately 736 billion KRW) in cash and dollar-denominated reserves.
Schiff had previously questioned Bitcoin's rally on September 22, suggesting MicroStrategy's additional Bitcoin purchases might have contributed to the upward trend. He also noted Saylor's optimistic stance on the stalled CLARITY Act as a potential factor behind the price movement. Additionally, Schiff argued that the growing adoption of tokenized stocks could weaken Bitcoin's investment appeal, with blockchain-based securities offering dividends and revenue generation as alternatives. This has raised questions about whether MicroStrategy's Bitcoin acquisitions are actually increasing per-share holdings and contributing to shareholder value.
Korean Source
This article is an English localization of a Korean-language crypto news report. Original headline: 피터 시프, 스트래티지 전략 정면 비판…"비트코인 수익률 -3.7%, 2026년 실패"