Preferred Shares Discounted Up to 63% Amid Governance Concerns

Some South Korean preferred shares are trading at prices up to 63% lower than their company's common shares, drawing criticism over capital allocation. The significant price disparity—difficult to explain solely by the lack of voting rights—is now raising questions about corporate governance and shareholder return policies. The Korea Corporate Governance Forum recently held a seminar titled 'Hidden Discount Problem in Korean Preferred Shares and Its Solutions,' discussing the undervaluation of domestic preferred shares. According to Yonhap Infomax, Samsung Electronics' preferred shares trade at around 25% below common shares, Hyundai Motor 2 Preferred B at 50%, and Doosan's preferred shares at a 60% discount. Preferred shares typically offer advantages in dividends or residual asset distribution compared to common shares in exchange for waiving voting rights. However, in South Korea, guaranteed dividends are often absent or limited to 1-2% of par value, resulting in a market-based dividend yield below 0.1%. The ranking for residual asset distribution is also the same as common shares, making them effectively 'voting-right-free common shares.' Comparisons with U.S. markets show stark differences: Alphabet's Class C shares (non-voting) trade at similar prices to voting Class A shares, and Berkshire Hathaway's Class B has a discount of only 1%. The price gap between common and preferred shares in South Korea is attributed partly to index inclusion practices and shareholder return policies. Major ETFs tracking indices like Kospi200 predominantly include common shares, pushing preferred shares out of passive investment flows. Corporate practices such as excluding preferred shares from share buybacks or public tender offers have also contributed to the discount. Sachin Mistry, Managing Director at Palliser Capital, stated that non-voting preferred shareholders must rely entirely on the board's commitment to protect their interests. He suggested that if boards actively work to improve preferred share value, it could signal governance improvements. Some investors argue that buying back preferred shares can be beneficial for common shareholders too. By purchasing cheaper preferred shares and canceling them, companies can reduce total shares more efficiently than with common shares, improving earnings per share. A foreign investor noted: 'If you have a factory that can be built at half the price, why would you choose to pay double? Management should explain such decisions.' The issue extends beyond cost efficiency. While canceling common shares increases voting rights ownership for major shareholders, canceling preferred shares has limited impact on controlling interest, suggesting the practice is more about corporate governance than just cost. Jeon Jong-eon, Managing Director of My Alpha Management Korea, said that low dividend payout ratios make it hard to attract investor interest in preferred shares. He suggested increasing dividend payouts to 60% could raise preferred share yields above double digits and reduce the discount gap to below 20%. Market movements include shareholder letters urging major companies to buy back preferred shares. Mirae Asset Securities and BYC have allocated significant portions of their share repurchase funds to preferred shares, while Hyundai Motor has formalized a balanced approach between common and preferred share purchases. Samsung Electronics is frequently cited as a representative case in the preferred share debate, with tensions around whether canceling common shares affects financial subsidiary ownership ratios versus reducing the preferred share discount gap. The issue also extends to crypto companies. For instance, Strategy (MSTR) recently used part of its common stock sale proceeds to repurchase STRC preferred shares. For digital asset treasury firms holding Bitcoin (BTC) and Ethereum (ETH), preferred share pricing and dividend structures are increasingly tied to financial stability beyond simple price trends. The Korean preferred share debate began as a general shareholder protection issue but now raises questions about how crypto treasury companies evaluate their capital structure.
Korean Source
This article is an English localization of a Korean-language crypto news report. Original headline: 우선주 최대 63% 할인, 이사회 책임론 나왔다