Quantum Computing Threat to Bitcoin and Ethereum Security Sparks Transition Debate

Quantum computing threats to the security of Bitcoin (BTC) and Ethereum (ETH) have resurfaced as a key issue in cryptocurrency security. The focus is not on immediate network collapse but rather on the need for assets and protocols with exposed public keys to prepare transition paths ahead of time.
Google Quantum AI published a paper on March 31 detailing new estimates for resources required to break the secp256k1-based 256-bit elliptic curve cryptography used by BTC and ETH. Researchers Ryan Babbush, Hartmut Neven, and Dan Boneh proposed configurations requiring fewer than 1200 logical qubits with under 90 million topological gates, or fewer than 1450 logical qubits with under 70 million topological gates.
The paper explains that with superconducting architecture, a physical error rate of 10^-3, and planar connectivity, circuit execution could take minutes with fewer than 500,000 physical qubits. Google's official blog urged the crypto industry to prepare for proactive transitions rather than reactive measures.
While this estimate does not mean quantum computers have already reached attack capability, it aligns with Google's stated goal of post-quantum cryptography transition by 2029, influencing timelines for big tech and standards bodies that will impact cryptocurrency wallets and custody infrastructure.
The potential attack scenario involves 'on-spend' attacks where public keys are reverse-engineered during transaction processing. BTC has a window between when transactions enter the mempool and get included in blocks, while ETH's shorter block times don't eliminate risk since public keys remain on-chain for already-transacted accounts.
Public key cryptography uses separate public and private keys: users sign transactions with private keys while networks verify using public keys. If quantum computers can reverse-engineer private keys from public keys, the security foundation of current signing systems could be undermined.
Ethereum's official documentation states that quantum computing poses a long-term threat to ECDSA, BLS signatures, KZG commitments, and zero-knowledge proofs, though it clarifies this is not an immediate threat. Ethereum's Lean Ethereum roadmap targets 2029 as the post-quantum transition milestone.
Bitcoin's issue centers more on consensus than technology. CoinDesk reported approximately 6.9 million BTC are exposed due to public key structures, representing an estimated exposure based on address types and transaction history rather than immediately stealable assets. While research proposals for quantum-resistant wallets and consensus changes exist in Bitcoin Core, they remain 'no plan' status.
Ethereum's top 1000 wallets hold around 20.5 million ETH, with at least 70 major private keys exposed on-chain. Existing smart contracts, bridges, and layer-2 solutions all require key replacement and code modifications. The Ethereum Magicians community is discussing combining post-quantum signatures with STARKs aggregation in proposals like EIP-8288.
Industry reactions are mixed: some advocate moving exposed assets quickly while others argue the threat timeline is much further away. Both views distance themselves from claims that current hardware can immediately break BTC and ETH. The U.S. National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) advises organizations using public key cryptography to transition to quantum-resistant systems now, with a plan to phase out vulnerable algorithms by 2035.
The cryptocurrency industry's focus is not on immediate price impacts but on storage structures. Exchanges, custodians, wallet providers, and bridge operators face varying transition burdens depending on their signing systems and key management approaches. The estimated public key exposure represents a risk assessment for prioritizing transitions rather than immediately stealable assets.
Google's paper, Ethereum documentation, and NIST timelines all point in the same direction: quantum attacks are not today's concern but cryptographic transitions won't happen overnight. Ethereum targets 2029 for its transition, while NIST plans to phase out vulnerable algorithms by 2035.
Korean Source
This article is an English localization of a Korean-language crypto news report. Original headline: 1200큐비트 추정, 비트코인·이더리움 전환 압박