Quantum Memory Could Replace Bitcoin or Break It, Oxford Scholar Says

There is no currently existing device considered the most important in cryptography. Oxford University lecturer Stefano Giuseppeo claims that quantum memory will decide whether Bitcoin (BTC) collapses or is replaced by something better.
Giuseppeo presented his argument on Tuesday, stating that the future of quantum cryptography now hinges solely on a single hardware build.
A quantum computing lecturer at Oxford University and co-founder of quantum security firm Spooky, Giuseppeo shared these views with BeInCrypto.
The bottleneck quantum money cannot overcome
BeInCrypto's expert committee previously concluded a report on unresolved issues. Quantum money cannot be forged because it is impossible to replicate quantum states.
However, no one can maintain this state for long periods. Even the best laboratory systems only preserve the state for seconds. Thus, discussions around quantum money remain theoretical.
Giuseppeo's article explains what conditions a practical device must meet: stability for months, ideally permanent; portability to fit in a container initially, then in pockets; and capacity to store billions of separate states.
He also notes that conventional quantum RAM is unsuitable. His design requires no random access or in-place editing—states are retrieved sequentially and discarded after use.
The gap between seconds and months is the core issue to solve.
Why Giuseppeo sees quantum memory as inevitable
His solution involves two steps. The first is straightforward: fault-tolerant quantum computers must maintain vulnerable states at scale, protected from noise over long periods—this is the essence of fault tolerance.
Giuseppeo argues that without computing functionality, what remains is a quantum memory device. Denying one denies the other.
This perspective has commercial implications. Billions have already been invested in fault-tolerant equipment, making memory an inevitable step within this strategic roadmap.
The second step concerns portability. Devices operating at ultra-low temperatures will likely remain on refrigerator floors for years to come.
Atom-based designs differ: information is naturally stored in separable properties. The problem shifts from physics to engineering challenges.
Giuseppeo also presents criteria often overlooked in discussions: memory does not need to survive decades. Even single-use sealed cartridges, used once and discarded on-site, suffice for all his mentioned purposes.
Applying this logic to cryptocurrency reveals an uncomfortable symmetry.
In March, Google Quantum AI analyzed Bitcoin attack costs with Ethereum Foundation and Stanford University, estimating fewer than 500,000 physical qubits would be needed. These devices require fault tolerance, which Giuseppeo defines as quantum memory.
This conclusion is uncomfortable for both sides: hardware capable of breaking Bitcoin's signatures can also implement quantum money.
Investment in fault-tolerant systems supports both futures simultaneously. In this narrative, there is no scenario where quantum computers break Bitcoin but an alternative becomes impossible.
Giuseppeo and Daniela Herman, CEO of quantum technology firm Dynex, elaborated on this logic during a panel discussion.
Why shipped goods stolen doesn't matter
This entire security model upends old assumptions. Traditional cryptographic keys are risky if exposed during transport—someone could copy them, transferring ownership without trace.
Entangled pairs hold no information while stored. Randomness only appears at the measurement moment.
Thus, even if containers are stolen during transit, suppliers lose inventory, not secrets. Giuseppeo writes that the worst outcome from a compromised supplier is an empty gas tank—useless but harmless.
The second consequence is more unusual: these resources deplete. Keys use entangled pairs, and money is consumed each time it's verified.
Giuseppeo calls this 'cryptocurrency via combustion.' Money made this way has a fuel gauge.
Q-Day has a schedule, but quantum money does not
The two axes of this story move at very different speeds.
On the attack side, clear dates exist. IBM predicts quantum computing will impact profitability by 2028 or 2029. Hong Kong requires banks to adopt quantum-resistant standards by 2030.
The U.S. National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) plans to phase out current elliptic curve signatures by 2030, banning them entirely from 2035 onward.
Conversely, the alternative technology has no schedule. Giuseppeo does not propose timelines; his article emphasizes that this resource is unavoidable but doesn't claim imminent product releases.
In panel discussions, he took a more forward-looking view: provably secure applications might emerge within 5–7 years. This estimate refers to broad quantum resource coverage, not just memory small enough for wallets.
Herman also mentioned similar limitations during the discussion.
What remains unaddressed
Someone must fill the memory. Thus, this creates a need for an issuer in systems known for having no managers.
Bill of lading without ledgers has no recovery method. Lost, stolen, or abandoned memories vanish with their value.
The industry continues developing these devices, but no direction is yet chosen.
Korean Source
This article is an English localization of a Korean-language crypto news report. Original headline: 양자 메모리…비트코인 깨고 대체하다