Ripple's Schwartz Challenges CFTC Stance on Kalshi Ruling

A dispute between federal and state regulators over Kalshi, a U.S. prediction market platform, has intensified after the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled on March 28 that Nevada gaming regulations can apply to Kalshi's sports event contracts.
Ripple (XRP) CTO emeritus David Schwartz criticized the ruling as "inaccurate" on X, arguing the core issue is whether Congress delegated regulatory authority over exchange-listed contracts, not the CFTC's broad jurisdiction. The Ninth Circuit determined Kalshi's sports contracts do not qualify as swaps under commodity law, allowing Nevada to apply gaming regulations while sending the election contract dispute back for further review.
Kalshi has argued that its status as a CFTC-registered Designated Contract Market (DCM) means federal regulation supersedes state rules. Nevada Gaming Control Board issued a cease-and-desist order on March 4, 2025, claiming Kalshi operates like an unlicensed sportsbook. The Ninth Circuit's split decision contrasts with the Third Circuit's April 6 ruling that New Jersey regulators cannot block Kalshi's sports contracts.
Legal expert Daniel Wallach argued CFTC rulemaking faces challenges under the major questions doctrine, which requires clear congressional delegation for significant regulatory actions. Schwartz countered by narrowing the focus to distinguish traditional sportsbooks from exchange-based products. Both comments were social media remarks, not court rulings.
Kalshi disclosed on March 27 that 20 states are involved in litigation over prediction market regulations, advocating for a national framework over state-by-state rules. The ruling signals potential regulatory fragmentation where sports contracts' legal status may vary by jurisdiction, impacting Kalshi's business model as it relies heavily on sports trading.
The CFTC reaffirmed its exclusive jurisdiction over commodity derivatives markets in a February 17 statement, citing risk hedging and price discovery functions. However, the Ninth Circuit did not accept this rationale for sports contracts. The case remains pending for election contract disputes, with further legal battles expected as courts divide on regulatory authority.
Korean Source
This article is an English localization of a Korean-language crypto news report. Original headline: 칼시 판결 후 리플 슈워츠, CFTC 쟁점 반박