Satoshi's 1.1M BTC Holdings Claim Revisited... Still Just Circumstantial Evidence

Whether approximately 1.1 million BTC mined in Bitcoin’s earliest days actually belonged to Satoshi Nakamoto remains reliant on circumstantial evidence, according to blockchain analysis.
On September 5, 2010, 600 BTC from blocks generated over four days were moved after 16 years—reigniting the debate. The coins originated from block rewards for 12 blocks created in March 2010. While the movement of these coins was noted, experts caution that this alone does not confirm they belonged to Satoshi.
Bitquery, a cryptocurrency research firm, analyzed the 12 blocks and found that 10 did not align with what is known as the 'Patoshi' pattern—early mining patterns. The remaining two showed only weak alignment, possibly coincidental. Bitquery analyst Gaurav Agarwal noted the transactions displayed traces of modern wallet software, suggesting the private key had likely been moved to a new environment.
The core issue lies in blockchain data reflecting control over keys rather than individuals. Agarwal explained that private keys can be inherited, sold, stolen, or recovered from secondhand storage devices, meaning the chain only records who held the keys at a given time—not necessarily Satoshi Nakamoto.
The 1.1 million BTC estimate originated from a 2013 analysis by researcher Sergio Demian Lerner, who identified unique patterns in Bitcoin’s early blocks and estimated a single miner accumulated about 1.1 million BTC. While Lerner still considers the calculation accurate, he emphasizes it remains circumstantial without mathematical proof or direct testimony.
Bitquery reanalyzed over 54,316 initial blocks and found a 99.2% match with the Patoshi list, with no exceptions in time-ordered checks of 5,836 adjacent block pairs.
The total amount varied depending on criteria: under strict application it fell short of 900,000 BTC, while the broadest estimate reached approximately 1.17 million BTC. The previously cited range of 1 million to 1.13 million BTC falls within this spectrum.
Agarwal broke down the common belief that Satoshi holds 1.1 million BTC into three points: strong evidence exists for coins being mined from a single machine, but proof that the machine belonged to Satoshi remains circumstantial; and simply because coins have not moved does not mean Satoshi still controls the private key.
Bitquery also highlighted a May 17, 2010 transaction where 600 BTC in early mining rewards were moved twice at one-hour intervals. This was interpreted as evidence that rewards from early March and late February 2009 had accumulated in the same wallet—a clear example of blockchain records showing connected mining rewards across multiple blocks.
However, the 600 BTC moved in September was not classified under Patoshi mining patterns. Even with newly confirmed on-chain data, no direct link to Satoshi’s holdings has been established. In conclusion, while it is highly likely that a single miner accumulated large early Bitcoin holdings, conclusive evidence proving this individual was Satoshi Nakamoto remains absent.
Korean Source
This article is an English localization of a Korean-language crypto news report. Original headline: 사토시 110만BTC 보유설 재조명…여전히 정황 증거뿐