Satoshi Questioned Over Bitcoin's Design as Claude NSA Curve Discovery Sparks Debate

For over 25 years, questions have lingered about the mathematical security of internet protocols. The U.S. National Security Agency (NSA) was suspected of secretly developing methods to decrypt them. Now, an AI model appears to have weakened that theory.
On Friday, Anthropic announced its Claude AI model solved a mystery that had perplexed cryptographers for decades in under 30 minutes.
What did Claude discover about the NSA? The controversy revolves around elliptic curves—mathematical rules used to verify digital signatures without revealing private keys.
In 2000, the U.S. National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) adopted several curves that included starting numbers provided by the NSA. No one explained where those numbers originated. Researchers suspected the NSA might have deliberately chosen numbers to create hidden vulnerabilities or backdoors.
Claude traced five sets of numbers from a simple program in 1997–1998 that generated seemingly random values using computer clocks. Now, anyone can reproduce the same results.
"Essentially, this result gives us greater confidence that the curves were chosen without backdoors or intentional vulnerabilities," said Anthropic.
The discovery has earned a $36,864 reward, which will be donated to charity.
However, questions remain about why certain numbers were skipped. While the likelihood of deliberate manipulation has decreased, it cannot be entirely ruled out.
Did Satoshi Make a Mistake by Avoiding NSA Curves? Bitcoin uses a different curve called secp256k1, designed with simple, publicly known numbers—leaving little room for suspicion. Satoshi Nakamoto never publicly explained why he chose this curve.
After Edward Snowden's 2013 revelations that the NSA had attempted to weaken other cryptographic standards, Bitcoin’s approach gained trust.
Nicolas Bacca, co-founder of Ledger, referred to "Checkmate Satoshi," arguing that the industry avoided NSA curves and opted for a more complex alternative.
Adam Back, CEO of Blockstream, countered by criticizing the NSA for not properly explaining its number selection.
No practical changes are expected for Bitcoin holders. Claude did not find vulnerabilities in Bitcoin’s cryptography, which remains secure against known real-world attacks.
Long-term concerns remain about quantum computing, which could ultimately threaten both Bitcoin and existing cryptographic systems.
Korean Source
This article is an English localization of a Korean-language crypto news report. Original headline: 사토시, 비트코인 잘못 설계했나…Claude NSA 발견 논란