SEC and CFTC Draw Regulatory Lines on DeFi 'Control' Authority

U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) Commissioner Hester Peirce stated that no separate legal exception is needed for peer-to-peer transactions conducted via unlicensed smart contracts.
According to blockchain media CryptoSlate, recent actions by the SEC and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) are focusing on where actual regulatory control resides rather than the DeFi label itself.
The key issue is how much authority software providers can hold. Peirce argued in a statement on April 17 that if intermediaries managing assets or facilitating trades disappear, regulatory logic weakens. She also referenced a 'truly decentralized structure,' though no formal legal category exists for this concept yet.
The SEC's concurrent order on tokenized securities provides clearer boundaries. This conditional exemption applies only to specific tokenized security exchanges (TSVs) that use automated market maker pools to support licensed trading, with the critical factor being who designates the pool, deploys contracts, modifies rules or parameters, sets fees, and halts transactions.
Peirce distinguished this structure from DeFi, stating licensed exchanges fall outside decentralized finance and unlicensed software represents a different model. Even if transactions are automated, regulatory considerations remain important if access, asset control, and operational authority stay in human hands.
The SEC also treats frontends as separate control layers. The SEC's Division of Trading and Markets stated in April that it would not pursue broker registration violations for interface providers allowing users to prepare trade instructions through self-custody wallets. However, this guidance lacks legal force and will be considered withdrawn after May 13, 2026, unless the Commission takes separate action.
Conversely, features with strong brokerage characteristics are excluded: recommending specific cryptocurrency securities, providing investment advice, holding or accessing user assets, executing trades directly, or processing orders. Fee structures also matter; flat fees or objectively determined rates are permissible, but commissions tied to trade volume or occurrence fall outside the scope due to potential influence on user choices.
The CFTC allows broader promotion and fee acceptance than the SEC but limits application to specific transaction structures. The CFTC's Market Participants Division stated in a staff letter 26-25 that it will not recommend enforcement against passive software providers who do not register as introducing brokers, provided users trade directly on designated contract markets or through registered market members.
The CFTC permits wider promotion of specific derivatives, directing users to registered entities, charging transaction-linked fees, and receiving a portion of registered entity revenue. However, it prohibits holding or controlling customer assets, providing explicit buy/sell signals, actively intervening in specific orders, or exercising discretion over order routing or execution. Written agreements, record-keeping, and disclosure requirements are also mandated.
Ultimately, regulatory judgment hinges not on the DeFi label but where control resides. Whether transactions execute automatically, regulatory application will vary based on who holds authority over access, assets, fees, and system changes or halts.
Korean Source
This article is an English localization of a Korean-language crypto news report. Original headline: 디파이 규제 가르는 '통제권'…美 SEC·CFTC가 따지는 기준은