SEC Crypto Rule Proposal Leaves Uncertainty Over Trading Market Status

The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has proposed a new regulatory framework for cryptocurrency-related investment contracts, but a legal analysis indicates it leaves uncertainty regarding the legal nature of trading in secondary markets. The SEC introduced its 'Regulation Crypto Assets' proposal on August 18, establishing a new registration exemption pathway with a $5 million cap ($69 million USD) over four years for initial issuance and up to $75 million ($1037 million USD) within 12 months for fundraising stages. The fundraising path includes financial reporting requirements and ongoing disclosure obligations.
The core of the proposal involves conditional safe harbors. If issuers fulfill promised 'essential management efforts' or permanently cease operations while meeting specified conditions, the cryptocurrency may no longer be considered an investment contract. Joseph Hall, a partner at Davis Polk & Wardwell, noted in a Bloomberg opinion piece that previous court rulings classified assets as securities not based on the land or oranges themselves but on investment contracts tied to orange grove businesses. He explained that even identical blockchain tokens could have different legal classifications depending on initial issuance and distribution methods.
Mr. Hall also argued it's difficult to determine the applicable legal framework from blockchain transaction records alone, making it challenging for trading platforms and intermediaries to assess securities status during secondary market transactions. The SEC acknowledged in its proposal that applying lower-tier standards to crypto assets is problematic. The framework's feature allowing assets initially classified as investment contracts to later fall outside this category conflicts with existing securities regulations.
While the SEC stated that safe harbors could increase predictability for issuers and market participants, it also left open the possibility that assets failing to meet safe harbor conditions might still not be considered investment contracts under lower-tier standards. The proposal is not yet final; the SEC plans to solicit public comments for 60 days following publication in the Federal Register.
Korean Source
This article is an English localization of a Korean-language crypto news report. Original headline: SEC 암호자산 공모안, 유통시장 증권성 판단은 남아