KOSUNI CRYPTO
Korea's Crypto Pulse, in English
$BTC $ETH $XRP $SOL $DOGE
Regulation
Neutral

SEC Divided on New ETF Review Process Amid Crypto Industry Debate

Published September 26, 2026 8:25 AM · 6 views $BTC
SEC Divided on New ETF Review Process Amid Crypto Industry Debate

The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has encountered diverging views within the crypto industry and traditional finance sector regarding its review process for new exchange-traded funds (ETFs). The debate centers not only on approval speed but also on non-public pre-consultations, automatic effectiveness procedures, and how to classify new ETFs.

The SEC announced in a June 30 document seeking public comments on ETFs involving crypto assets, commodity-based instruments, single-stock strategies, leverage, options-based strategies, private assets, and event contracts. The comment period closed on August 31, following a 60-day window after the Federal Register publication.

The SEC’s inquiry aims to determine whether existing investment company laws and ETF rules can adequately handle complex product structures. New ETFs refer to those with underlying assets or management strategies more intricate than traditional stock or bond ETFs.

Grayscale proposed non-public pre-consultations and a 45-day staff response process, arguing it would reduce duplicate filings. The firm cited issues during the GDLC listing transition where approval by staff overlapped with committee review and stay of effectiveness, causing market and operational uncertainty.

Andersen Horowitz also called for expediting reviews without compromising thoroughness, suggesting parallel processing of registration and exchange listing reviews through electronic submissions and standardized disclosures. Crypto Council for Innovation (CCI) supported voluntary pre-consultations but warned against procedures that could delay or halt automatic effectiveness.

Crypto industry advocates emphasized predictable timelines over speed alone. Issuers argued lengthy public review periods risk competitor imitation and market confusion. In contrast, Charles Schwab opposed full non-public processes, stating transparency provides time for brokers and market participants to prepare investor education, risk disclosures, and monitoring systems. The firm proposed a minimum 75-day public disclosure period before effectiveness.

Jane Street warned that rushed registration could lead to less competitive products with lower liquidity, stressing the importance of proper structure for ETFs to track net asset value closely. They noted individual investors might face wider bid-ask spreads without adequate structural review.

Another key debate involves whether the SEC should treat new ETFs as a single category or differentiate them based on product type. Andersen Horowitz and Charles Schwab argued that crypto-based ETPs and private asset exposure products differ in market structure, valuation, liquidity, and investor protection needs. Reuters reported market participants expressed concerns over the broad 'new ETF' label and ambiguous definitions.

As U.S. markets see Bitcoin (BTC) and Ethereum (ETH) related products trading as regulated instruments, the next focus for SEC will be how quickly and through what disclosure processes these new products emerge.

Korean Source

This article is an English localization of a Korean-language crypto news report. Original headline: SEC 신종 ETF 심사 논의, 공개성 두고 갈렸다