KOSUNI CRYPTO
Korea's Crypto Pulse, in English
$BTC $ETH $XRP $SOL $DOGE
DeFi
Neutral

Solana Proposes Alternative to Failed Transaction Approval Reuse

Published October 13, 2026 2:49 AM · 7 views $SOL
Solana Proposes Alternative to Failed Transaction Approval Reuse

Solana (SOL) has proposed an alternative to its existing durable nonce feature, which supports offline signing. The proposed programs would allow reusing transaction approvals even if execution fails, but require separate handling for approval expiration and cancellation.

The Solana Foundation outlined Anza's Programmatic Signer and Blueshift's Vector as candidate alternatives in a plan announced October 2026. Durable nonce allows submitting offline-signed transactions by embedding a value stored in an account into the transaction, even after the valid period of the recent block hash has expired. Under current implementation, if a transaction fails during execution after verification, the nonce is consumed and fees are charged.

Both candidates sign messages containing execution details instead of directly signing offline keys for transactions. On-chain programs verify signatures before granting permissions to derived addresses (PDAs), with online relayers submitting transactions. This allows handling both execution and nonce changes in a single transaction; if execution fails, the nonce reverts, enabling reuse of the same approval message.

However, this introduces challenges managing approval expiration periods, as pending approvals could execute later if nonces remain unchanged. The Solana Foundation suggests resolving this by either successfully executing transactions that consume the same nonce first or including expiration instructions within transactions.

Neither candidate includes default expiration functionality. Programmatic Signer signs only the execution content embedded in approval messages, allowing relayers to add instructions before and after. Vector bundles all top-level transaction instructions into signatures, preventing relayers from adding, deleting, or rearranging instructions—requiring separate expiration instructions instead.

Transitioning requires additional checks beyond signature program approvals: verifying wallet and token account ownership and withdrawal/mint/burn permissions for stake accounts, migrating to new PDAs, and ensuring applications support cross-program invocation (CPI). Applications blocking CPI or allowing only top-level transaction instructions, as well as Token-2022's CPI Guard settings, may conflict with the new approach.

The Solana Foundation has proposed phasing out durable nonce but hasn't finalized the alternative or retirement date. After both candidate programs complete audits and mainnet deployment, a six-month transition period is planned. Current status shows Programmatic Signer is at devnet stage with ongoing audit, while Vector's program address is public but audit status remains unclear.

Existing durable nonce will remain available for use. Custody provider Fireblocks agreed to phasing out durable nonce but noted that PDA permission migration and CPI compatibility could pose challenges for large-scale operations and certain DeFi applications during transition. Some participants in the Solana improvement proposal discussion suggested exploring transaction envelopes or Sudo approaches, advocating for longer transition periods.

Korean Source

This article is an English localization of a Korean-language crypto news report. Original headline: 솔라나, 실패 거래 승인 재사용할 대체 서명안 제시