Regulation
Neutral
Stablecoin Regulation: The Real Test Lies in Distribution

Stablecoins denominated in dollars. Source: Generated by ChatGPT
Kim Hyobong’s Legal Crypto is a column series covering digital asset legislation and policy trends both domestically and internationally. Experts including Kim Hyobong, a legal specialist at Taepyeongyang Law Firm, along with certified public accountant Choi Hee-kyung and lawyer Woo Ji-won, provide insights into the latest regulatory developments in digital assets. On October 8, the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) issued an opinion regarding stablecoins that do not meet the requirements of the Markets in Crypto-Assets (MiCA) regulation. Under MiCA, authorized crypto asset service providers (CASP) must refrain from offering services related to such non-compliant stablecoins to European Union (EU) clients. This includes trading, exchange, order execution, transfer, custody, and investment advice—effectively covering all virtual asset services. The key point is the rationale: risks arising from insufficient regulatory compliance by issuers—such as lack of repayment obligations, inadequate reserve management, or governance issues—cannot be mitigated solely through intermediary management or user disclosure. Therefore, authorized providers must adhere to their duty under MiCA Article 66(1) to act in the best interest of clients, necessitating restrictions on services involving non-compliant coins. If compliant and non-compliant stablecoin issuers bear equal costs for regulation, but both types trade through the same distribution channels, regulatory effectiveness will be undermined. However, existing holders are provided an exit strategy: new acquisitions are restricted, while selling, converting, transferring, or withdrawing existing holdings can be temporarily permitted under national supervisory authority discretion. Italy’s financial regulator (CONSOB) has reaffirmed this approach within a week, indicating ongoing coordination among member states. This is not a novel concept. Similar to stocks and funds, mere legal issuance does not exempt sellers and intermediaries from their obligations. Trust in financial products is built through the collective responsibility of all parties involved in delivering those products to clients. ESMA’s opinion applies this principle to stablecoins. Domestic legislative discussions have focused on issuer qualifications, bank participation, and reserve management—natural steps toward establishing a foundation of trust. However, even with stringent issuance requirements, if non-compliant stablecoins continue to be traded freely through domestic exchanges and other distribution channels, regulatory impact will be significantly reduced. Currently, some users purchase dollar-denominated stablecoins on domestic exchanges and transfer them to personal wallets for use in overseas decentralized finance (DeFi) services. However, the legal jurisdiction applicable at each stage of this process remains unclear, creating complexity. Further design is needed regarding standards for handling foreign-issued stablecoins domestically, cross-border circulation of won-denominated stablecoins, and user protection mechanisms during payment processes. Regulatory scope should also be differentiated appropriately among service providers. Wallets where users manage private keys directly, custodial services holding client assets, and platforms facilitating actual transactions differ in function and risk exposure, requiring corresponding adjustments to their obligations. Whether a provider merely offers technology, mediates transactions, or controls user assets could serve as the basis for such differentiation. Balancing innovation without stifling it while preventing 'technology provision' from becoming an evasion route for issuance regulation is essential. Given that cross-border assets must be regulated under national laws, alignment with international regulations should also be considered during the design phase. Stablecoin trust cannot be achieved through issuance alone; it must be maintained across all stages—storage, transfer, and payment. Regulation must extend beyond issuer qualifications to include distribution conditions and associated responsibilities. The success of stablecoin regulation hinges on what happens after issuance.Korean Source
This article is an English localization of a Korean-language crypto news report. Original headline: [칼럼] 스테이블코인 제도화, 진짜 시험대는 '유통'