Stock Tokens' Success Hinges on Shareholder Rights and Redemption Terms

The success of stock token ventures hinges not merely on listing shares on a blockchain, but on whether token holders possess specific rights and under what conditions they can be redeemed. Even if a token's name includes a particular company's stock, this does not guarantee actual shareholder rights. A post by Wu Blockchain re-sharing analysis from 0xRickyW categorizes stock tokens into three types: direct/indirect equity tokens representing real shares, certificate-based tokens issued against third-party held shares, and derivative-type tokens that track share prices without granting ownership.
The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) staff materials explain that tokenized securities' structure determines holder rights, noting that tokens tracking share prices without providing ownership may not confer rights to the underlying company. Thus, it's essential to examine both the collateral asset backing a token and the actual rights holders can exercise. When issuers differ from stock custodians, counterparty risks like issuer bankruptcy may arise.
Selling tokens differs from redemption: selling involves transferring tokens to another buyer, while redemption requires the issuer to follow its process to buy back tokens for cash, stablecoins, or securities. Simply purchasing a token does not automatically grant redemption rights; eligibility, fees, and processing times depend on product terms. Token balances recorded on blockchain do not automatically sync with underlying share custody records or customer accounts, requiring reconciliation across issuers, brokers, custodians, and apps to handle corporate actions like dividends or stock splits.
While tokens can trade over weekends when stock markets are closed, this does not mean underlying share trading or redemption processes occur simultaneously. Reduced market liquidity may cause token prices to diverge from underlying shares. The analysis suggests three business opportunities: creating portfolio products allowing investors to hold and adjust investments directly; developing operational software for reconciling records across issuers, brokers, custodians, and apps to handle exceptions like failed trades or delayed redemptions; and building infrastructure for valuation, risk management, and liquidation when tokens are used as collateral. Some products already support collateralized lending, such as Kamino's feature allowing users to pledge certain xStocks for USDC loans.
Korean Source
This article is an English localization of a Korean-language crypto news report. Original headline: 주식 토큰, 주주권·상환 조건이 사업성 가른다