US Court Rejects Gemini's Request to Cancel CFTC Settlement

U.S. cryptocurrency exchange Gemini sought to cancel its existing settlement with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), but a New York federal court has rejected the request. The court ruled that while regulators admitted issues in the litigation process, there was insufficient grounds to overturn the agreement.
According to Bloomberg on May 15 (local time), Judge Alvin Hellerstein dismissed Gemini and CFTC's joint motion to vacate the settlement order. The court cited that Gemini had voluntarily agreed to settle just three weeks before trial as a key reason for its decision.
In 2022, the CFTC sued Gemini over allegedly misleading information provided during the review of Bitcoin futures products. In January 2023, Gemini paid $5 million in civil penalties and accepted a permanent injunction prohibiting it from making false or misleading statements to the CFTC.
However, following the Trump administration's return to power, the CFTC changed its position. After internal review identified issues with evidence reliability and litigation procedures, the agency jointly requested with Gemini on May 5 to vacate the settlement order, stating that under current enforcement standards, such a case would not have been filed initially.
Both parties argued that the original agreement violated fundamental principles of fair law enforcement. But Judge Hellerstein determined that circumstances alone did not justify overturning the existing order. Even if Gemini later obtained additional evidence leading to regret over its decision, he ruled that the factual situation had not changed enough to make continued application of the order unfair.
Korean Source
This article is an English localization of a Korean-language crypto news report. Original headline: 美 법원, CFTC '제미니 제재 취소' 요청 기각