US SEC and CFTC Jointly Classify Bitcoin, Ethereum, XRP as Non-Securities

The US Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) and Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) have jointly classified Bitcoin, Ethereum, and XRP as non-securities in principle.
On May 5, CFTC Chairman Michael Selig outlined a proposed framework for cryptocurrency trading rules at a symposium hosted by New York's Fordham University School of Law. The proposal focuses on separating leveraged, margin-based, and loan-backed individual transactions into a new federal regulatory category.
The CFTC plans to introduce a new registration classification called 'cryptocurrency market' for exchanges handling such transactions. It also launched a public comment period regarding the regulation of retail cryptocurrency trading, with comments due within 60 days of publication in the Federal Register.
Selig divided exchanges into three tiers: Tier 1 for general spot exchanges under state money transmission regulations; Tier 2 for platforms offering margin, leverage, and loans; and Tier 3 for those handling derivatives like perpetual futures. The proposal targets Tier 2 operators.
He emphasized the framework is based on existing authority rather than new legislation, stating that exchanges can choose between state licensing or federal registration. 'Only Congress can mandate registration for all exchanges,' he noted. He also highlighted that while Congress has required CFTC registration for margin-based retail trading, the commission had previously enforced rules without dedicated regulations.
The proposal clarifies which cryptocurrencies may be subject to regulation. Selig cited a joint SEC-CFTC interpretation stating that digital commodities, collectibles, and tools are generally non-securities. Examples include Bitcoin, Ethereum, XRP, Solana, Stellar, and Tezos as digital commodities whose value forms through programmatic operation or supply-demand dynamics.
New registration requirements include controls on listing stages, requiring exchanges to prove they are not vulnerable to price manipulation at launch. Exchanges holding customer assets in consolidated accounts would also need to provide reserve proof, bringing both listing reviews and asset custody under federal oversight.
The proposal also clarifies 'actual delivery' rules under the Commodity Exchange Act. Selig stated that if users transfer crypto directly to external non-custodial wallets within 28 days, it will be considered compliant with the 'actual delivery' requirement, treating direct transfers outside exchanges as physical delivery.
Regulators are prioritizing reforms for leveraged and loan-based retail trading rather than blanket federal registration for spot cryptocurrency transactions. By classifying major cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin, Ethereum, and XRP as non-securities, they have set a benchmark for future exchange registration, listing reviews, and custody regulations.
Korean Source
This article is an English localization of a Korean-language crypto news report. Original headline: 美 SEC·CFTC "비트코인·이더리움·XRP, 원칙적 비증권" 공동 해석