US SEC and CFTC Face Scrutiny Over Centralized Crypto Regulation Amid Staff Vacancies

With the delay in processing U.S. virtual asset market structure legislation, concerns have emerged about the concentration of regulatory power among a few commissioners at financial regulatory bodies.
CoinTelegraph reported on Tuesday (local time) that only three commissioners currently hold key regulatory decision-making roles at the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC). Both agencies are mandated to have five commissioners each, but staffing vacancies have left approximately $3 trillion in virtual asset market regulation dependent on a small number of officials.
The SEC has only Chairman Paul Atkins and Commissioner Mark Uyeda remaining after Hester Peirce stepped down earlier this month. At the CFTC, Michael Slicker has served as chairman since December last year following Senate confirmation, making him the sole commissioner currently in office. Two of the three commissioners at both agencies were appointed by former President Donald Trump.
In this context, both agencies are advancing virtual asset regulatory reforms using existing legal authority, separate from congressional legislation. The SEC proposed a safe harbor for companies in August to clarify that certain tokens do not qualify as investment contracts. The CFTC has begun drafting regulations for exchanges this month, with Chairman Slicker stating he aims to formalize the virtual asset oversight framework under current law.
Notably, the SEC recently eased quorum requirements, raising concerns about concentrated decision-making power. On October 30, the agency revised its rules, effective October 2, allowing a single commissioner to form a quorum under certain conditions when only two commissioners remain. Critics warn this could lead to excessive concentration of rulemaking authority among few officials.
Commissioner Uyeda defended the move as necessary for normal agency operations in his Financial Times op-ed, stating that the change clarifies how a quorum can be formed when other commissioners cannot participate in specific matters, and refuting claims that it was altered to allow a small number of commissioners to unilaterally decide regulations.
Meanwhile, the White House has not announced additional nominees to fill vacancies at the SEC or CFTC as of Tuesday. This suggests the current commissioner structure will likely remain unchanged for the foreseeable future.
Congressional processing of the Clarify Act (CLARITY Act), which aims to regulate virtual asset market structures, remains unresolved. Some experts believe legislative progress is unlikely before the November midterm elections or the new Congress convenes in January 2025.
Korean Source
This article is an English localization of a Korean-language crypto news report. Original headline: 美 SEC·CFTC, 인력 공백 속 가상자산 규제 정비…"소수 위원 권한 집중 우려"